Average Customer Review:
( 9 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 12 found the following review helpful:
Terrible - I Tried Both - Buy TurboTax for Business Instead!Feb 09, 2004
By Obamanomics
""Let's Spend Our Way Out of Recession""
Hi Everyone,I am in the unfortunate position of having bought BOTH TurboTax and TaxCut, so I can give a first-hand comparison. Since I'm limited to 1,000 words, I'll give one example and my opinion: SPARE YOURSELF AND BUY TURBOTAX. I am is the President & CEO of a small S-corporation. I am also cheap. I thought I'd save a few dollars and purchase TaxCut Premium instead of TurboTax for Business - my thinking was that I'd be looking out for the "little guy" developers while saving my pennies. End result: I had too many problems to list. The software was buggy and hard to understand (at one point I lost my return data by downloading updates for all forms - this causes an array overflow in TaxCut). More importantly, the TaxCut interview is terrible, almost non-existent. As an example: my company was first incorporated this year. That means I can amortize startup and organizational expenses, but in order to do so I need to attach an election statement. TaxCut gave me no way to make this election, and no interview whatsoever to cover that topic. Their "interview" just tells me to fill out form 4562, section VI (which I could do with a pencil). I finally got so fed up with TaxCut that I bought TurboTax to compare the two products. I suspected that TurboTax might be more capable. I was right. Back that the startup expenses example: TurboTax immediately deduced that I was a new corporation from my short tax year, SUGGESTED that I make the election, and provided the appropriate statement forms. Fantastic! This is only one of hundreds of examples...but space permitting, I am trying to do you a favor: don't be penny wise and pound foolish - buy TurboTax.
4 of 4 found the following review helpful:
BEWARE of the Business ProductMar 10, 2004
By Leo TaxCut Business has many problems. I am suprised that it is even on the market. This product does not even deserve 1 star! The interview is not exhaustive. The user must have a fair amount of tax knowledge to adequately utilize the software. The interview does not suggest forms that should be used. The update process corrupted my data. A long session with tech support concluded with me re-entering the return. After this pain, for some reason, I decided to stick with it and download the state business product. After much work, the return would not print because the forms had not been approved by the state. When I asked customer service about this, they assured me that approved forms would be available in a few weeks. Well, as of this writing it is 3/9/04. Business returns are due on 3/15/04. Exactly how long should I wait for "approved" forms? All in all, the product is difficult to use. If you are not an advanced computer & software user, you will really feel some pain. I could go on, but read the other reviews, some good points are brought up. I'm on the way to return the product for a refund.
3 of 3 found the following review helpful:
Use At Your Own RiskMar 28, 2004
By Michael Belfiore I selected this product because it was the only comprehensive business product I could download (why pay for and wait for shipping if you can avoid it?). I experienced many of the problems of the other reviewers, including: --Gaps in the interview process that simply refer you to IRS instructions. --Software refused to launch after installing state product, requiring a reinstall. Fortunately, I had already printed out a draft of my return, so I'm just looking at having to do some data entry rather than start from scratch. --State product for my state (NY) was worse than the free, fill-in version of the form available from the New York State website. Not only did it simply display the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance instructions instead of walking me through my return, but the "updated" form refused to print because, according to the software, it wasn't approved by New York State. Fortunately, TaxCut offers a no-questions-asked refund, which I took them up on for the state business product. Because the refund is for a downloaded product, I didn't have to mail any disks back or fill out any forms to get my refund. I'm sticking with TaxCut, bugs and all, for my federal return because it is less than half the price of TurboTax , and because I don't want to pay for and wait for shipping of a product I have no way of knowing is any better. Here's what I suggest for other intrepid souls who wish to use TaxCut to file their business returns: --View the product for what it is: simply an aid to filling out your own taxes. --Become thoroughly familiar with your own tax situation; get tax books and download the IRS forms and instructions as well. Don't rely on the software to know anything you don't--and be pleasantly surprised when it does. --Check your completed return carefully for any anomalies (mine inexplicably included a form I didn't need). --Do not purchase the state product; you'll do much better with the interactive forms available from your state website.
3 of 3 found the following review helpful:
Worst software I've ever tried to useMar 18, 2004
I purchased this software based on reviews I read on Amazon where Turbo Tax wasn't rated as highly on the day I was researching. In reading the reviews today, I am gratified to learn that my problems were common among other users. The problems I encountered were extreme difficulty installing the software and then not having updates available yet. When they finally were available, then I had trouble getting the updates to download and function properly. I had a problem getting assistance because the help people operate on East Coast time so they aren't available in the evenings when I'm working on this. I cannot believe that any product related to taxes would provide such limited hours of support. Long and short - after about 6 frustrating days, I gave up on TaxCut. I went to the IRS and my state website and downloaded extension forms as I had run out of time, patience, and sanity. For the aggravation I just experienced, I want to warn anyone else that this software is horrible. Since I had to do so much uninstalling and reinstalling, my computer is noticeably slower than before my Tax Cut experience. I hope that I didn't screw up my computer as they had me doing all kinds of things to it to try to get the software to download. They said the registry was not fully installing for some reason. Now I think maybe my computer was trying to tell me something - like "please don't load this garbage into my hard drive" - STAY AWAY FROM TAX CUT HOME & BUSINESS!
3 of 3 found the following review helpful:
IF YOU NEED 1041 YOU ARE STUCK WITH THISFeb 12, 2004
By South of Boston I have used the personal Taxcut for years and love it....I needed to file a 1041 for a family trust beginning last year so I looked into the business version of Turbotax and Taxcut...Turbotax didn't list a 1041, so I had to get Taxcut Home and Business....The 1041 form was buggy and frustrating (save your work often) but I managed to produce the forms and attachments eventually even though inexperienced in trust taxes...a word to the wise: don't wait until the last minute to download upgrades (you get a program "shell" in the box and almost everything must be downloaded from H&R Block)...I had to file for extension --not a major hassle since it's automatic and for 6 months with business taxes-- because I couldn't get the upgrades pre-April 15th.
See all 9 customer reviews on Amazon.com
|